Bonding · Human-reviewed original
Question
Pure sucrose dissolves in purified water mainly as neutral molecules. A similar amount of NaCl dissolves as ions. Which comparison best explains the difference in electrical conductivity?
- Sucrose carries current more strongly because its molecules are larger.
- NaCl is conductive because all sodium atoms remain metallic.
- NaCl supplies mobile charged solute particles, while sucrose supplies mainly neutral solute particles.
- Both solutes supply the same ion count because their solutions contain water.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: NaCl supplies mobile charged solute particles, while sucrose supplies mainly neutral solute particles.
Conduction requires charge carriers that can move through the solution. The specified NaCl solution has sodium and chloride ions, while sucrose remains largely molecular. Thus the salt contributes substantial mobile ionic charge; purified water autoionization does not erase the solute-dependent comparison. Option review: A: Molecular size does not supply the mobile charges required for ionic conduction. B: Dissolved sodium chloride contains sodium ions, not metallic sodium atoms. C: Mobile dissolved ions can carry charge; neutral sucrose molecules do not provide a comparable ionic current. D: The solvent does not make every neutral molecular solute dissociate into ions.