Gases · Human-reviewed original
Question
In a supplied low-pressure model, the Joule–Thomson coefficient is μ_JT=[2a/(RT)−b]/C_p, with C_p>0. Let a=2.000 L² bar mol⁻², b=0.05000 L mol⁻¹ and R=0.08314 L bar mol⁻¹ K⁻¹. For an isenthalpic pressure drop, which comparison between 500 K and 1500 K follows?
- 500 K cools and 1500 K warms.
- Both temperatures remain unchanged because the process is isenthalpic.
- Both temperatures cool because pressure always falls.
- 500 K warms and 1500 K cools.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: 500 K cools and 1500 K warms.
Set the bracket to zero to obtain T_inv=2a/(Rb)=4.000/(0.08314×0.05000)≈962 K. At 500 K the bracket is positive, while at 1500 K it is negative. Use ΔT≈μ_JTΔP with ΔP<0: positive μ_JT cools and negative μ_JT warms. Isenthalpic throttling differs from a fixed-internal-energy free expansion. Option review: A: The inversion temperature is about 962 K; μ_JT is positive below it and negative above it, so a pressure drop has the stated effects. B: Constant enthalpy does not require constant temperature for a nonideal gas. C: The temperature response to throttling depends on the sign of μ_JT, which changes across the inversion temperature. D: This reverses the sign relation between μ_JT and a negative pressure change.