Thermodynamics · Human-reviewed original
Question
For a reaction at fixed T, ΔG°=0 and the current reaction quotient is Q=5.00. Activities are dimensionless and T>0. Which thermodynamic statement is correct?
- The equilibrium constant equals the current Q=5.00.
- The system is necessarily at equilibrium because ΔG° is zero.
- A catalyst would make ΔG° negative and favor the forward direction.
- The forward direction has ΔG=RTln5>0, so the reverse direction is favored.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: The forward direction has ΔG=RTln5>0, so the reverse direction is favored.
Use ΔG°=−RTlnK to identify K=1 for the specified reaction. At the present composition, ΔG=ΔG°+RTlnQ=RTln5, which is positive. The reverse direction lowers Gibbs free energy until Q approaches K; zero standard free energy does not mean every composition is equilibrated. Option review: A: The equilibrium constant is fixed by ΔG° and temperature, not by an arbitrary current composition. B: Zero standard reaction free energy sets K=1, but the current Q differs from one. C: Catalysis does not change standard-state thermodynamic free energy or equilibrium constant. D: The actual reaction free energy depends on the current quotient as well as the standard-state value.