USNCO Prep
FREE PUBLIC SAMPLE · SEL-0123

Identical gases and the apparent mixing paradox

Check your answer against worked feedback. Public samples do not change your saved progress.

Thermodynamics · Human-reviewed original

Question

Two equal compartments contain the same ideal gas at identical temperature and pressure. Removing the partition changes no intensive state and no molecule is physically distinguishable by compartment of origin. Which entropy assessment is appropriate?

  1. There is no thermodynamic mixing entropy change from treating identical molecules as two species.
  2. Temperature must fall because each labeled group doubles its available volume.
  3. A positive entropy change of 2nRln2 must be assigned to mixing the compartment labels.
  4. Entropy decreases because the partition is removed.
Show answer and explanation

Answer: There is no thermodynamic mixing entropy change from treating identical molecules as two species.

The two compartments have the same gas identity, temperature, pressure and density. After removing the partition, the full sample retains those intensive conditions; no distinct chemical components have mixed. Assigning separate species to unobservable origin labels would spuriously count entropy. The thermodynamic mixing entropy is zero for the stipulated identical gas. Option review: A: The initial and final gas have the same density and chemical identity; the artificial origin labels add no physical mixing entropy. B: No energy or physical composition change requires cooling in this ideal identical-gas process. C: Labels of origin are not distinct chemical species and cannot be counted as mixing components here. D: Removing the redundant partition does not create a decrease in thermodynamic entropy under the stated identical states.

Browse all free practice questions →

Try it interactively

Loading training data