Equilibrium · Human-reviewed original
Question
A solid-state reaction has two pure solid phases coexisting with a gas at equilibrium. At fixed temperature and vessel volume, add more of one already-present solid without changing phase identity. What follows in the usual pure-solid activity model?
- The equilibrium gas pressure must double.
- The equilibrium constant increases with the solid mass.
- The gas pressure rises in proportion to the total solid mass.
- The equilibrium gas pressure is unchanged while both required solids remain present.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: The equilibrium gas pressure is unchanged while both required solids remain present.
For an existing pure solid phase, the usual activity is one rather than proportional to its amount. Adding more of that same phase changes inventory but not its activity. At fixed temperature, the same gas coexistence condition remains in force as long as both required solid phases are still present. Option review: A: Adding an amount of a pure solid does not double its unit activity. B: The thermodynamic constant at fixed temperature does not depend on how much of an existing pure phase is present. C: Pure-solid inventory does not enter the coexistence pressure while both phases remain present. D: The pure-solid activities stay one, so adding their inventory does not change the coexistence pressure.