Equilibrium · Human-reviewed original
Question
An ideal-gas equilibrium A(g)⇌2B(g) is perturbed by adding an inert gas at the same temperature. Compare a rigid vessel with a movable piston maintaining total pressure. Which comparison is correct?
- Both cases leave reactive partial pressures unchanged.
- Both cases shift toward A because total gas amount increases.
- The rigid vessel has no shift; the constant-pressure piston expands and favors B.
- The rigid vessel shifts toward B and the constant-pressure piston is unchanged.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: The rigid vessel has no shift; the constant-pressure piston expands and favors B.
In the rigid vessel, the amounts of A and B, T and V are unchanged immediately, so their partial pressures and Q are unchanged. At constant total pressure, inert-gas addition expands the mixture, reducing both reactive partial pressures by a common factor f<1. For Q=p_B²/(p_Ap°), the quotient scales by f and falls below K, favoring the side with two gas molecules. Option review: A: Only the rigid-vessel case holds reactive partial pressures fixed when inert gas is added. B: At fixed volume reactive partial pressures are unchanged; at fixed total pressure the expanding volume favors the higher-gas-mole side. C: Fixed V leaves n_iRT/V unchanged, while expansion at fixed total P reduces reactive partial pressures and favors dissociation. D: This reverses the volume response and its equilibrium consequence.