Acids and bases · Human-reviewed original
Question
Water reacts with HCl to form H₃O⁺, and with NH₃ to form OH⁻ and NH₄⁺. Which description of water follows from these two reactions?
- Water acts as a base with HCl and as an acid with NH₃.
- Water is only a proton acceptor.
- Water changes oxidation state in both reactions.
- Water is only a proton donor.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: Water acts as a base with HCl and as an acid with NH₃.
A Brønsted base accepts a proton, while a Brønsted acid donates one. In the HCl reaction, water gains a proton to become H₃O⁺. In the ammonia reaction, water loses a proton to become OH⁻; its acid or base role depends on its reaction partner. Option review: A: Its roles follow proton acceptance and donation in the two respective reactions. B: Formation of OH⁻ requires water to donate a proton to NH₃. C: These are proton-transfer reactions and do not require an oxidation-state change. D: Formation of H₃O⁺ requires water to accept a proton from HCl.