Acids and bases · Human-reviewed original
Question
Two monoprotic acids HA and HB are compared at the same temperature in the same dilute aqueous standard-state convention. K_a(HA)=10⁻³ and K_a(HB)=10⁻⁶. Which conclusion is warranted?
- Both acids must be completely ionized at all concentrations.
- HA has the larger tendency to donate its proton to water.
- HA must have the larger molar concentration in every sample.
- HB is stronger because its K_a is smaller.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: HA has the larger tendency to donate its proton to water.
Compare constants only under the same temperature and standard-state convention. The dissociation reaction places proton donation to water on the product side. HA has a thousandfold larger dissociation constant, so it is stronger; this comparison does not specify sample concentrations. Option review: A: Finite weak-acid constants do not guarantee complete ionization at arbitrary concentration. B: The larger K_a corresponds to greater thermodynamic dissociation tendency under the common convention. C: Acid strength is not an imposed analytical concentration. D: A smaller dissociation constant favors the undissociated acid more strongly.