Inorganic chemistry · Human-reviewed original
Question
In an ideal octahedral crystal-field model, the five d orbitals split into t₂g and e_g sets with separation Δ_o. Which relative energies preserve the d-orbital barycenter?
- Three t₂g at +0.4Δ_o and two e_g at −0.6Δ_o
- Three t₂g at −0.5Δ_o and two e_g at +0.5Δ_o
- Two t₂g at −0.4Δ_o and three e_g at +0.6Δ_o
- Three t₂g at −0.4Δ_o and two e_g at +0.6Δ_o
Show answer and explanation
Answer: Three t₂g at −0.4Δ_o and two e_g at +0.6Δ_o
Octahedral symmetry gives a threefold t₂g set and a twofold e_g set. Let lower shift be −a and upper shift b, with a+b=Δ_o. Barycenter conservation requires −3a+2b=0, yielding a=0.4Δ_o and b=0.6Δ_o. Option review: A: This reverses the standard octahedral energy ordering: orbitals directed toward the ligands are raised. B: Equal shifts do not compensate unequal degeneracies. C: This interchanges the degeneracies and does not preserve the weighted barycenter. D: The weighted sum 3(−0.4)+2(0.6)=0 and separation is one Δ_o.